Digital Dictionary of Buddhism

DDB Top Page 
 
 
  XML source

但理隨緣

Pronunciations

Basic Meaning: exclusive principle conforms to conditions

Senses:

  • Also rendered as 別理隨緣 (Skt. anyatva). This describes the Off-Mountain 山外 Tiantai 天台 views of principle that are informed by the Huayan 華嚴 teachings. For both Huayan and Tiantai, the coherence of all phenomena in the universe is present in a single thought-moment 一念 in a single sentient being. However, only Tiantai holds fast to the notion that every single moment of existence is the whole of reality manifesting in this particular form, as this particular moment of existence. Since both the enlightened cognition of the Buddha and the deluded cognition of unenlightened sentient beings in the other nine realms both contain all dharmas or 'quiddities'  具足一切法, past, present, and future, the object of contemplation is fundamentally the same across all ten realms (Mou 1989, vol. 2, 1105). Each thought-moment, whether 'pure' , 'impure' , or 'karmically neutral' at its surface level, is, at a deeper level, inherently mixed together with all other dharmas of all three moral grades. What matters for determining the surface-level moral grade of a particular thought is the way it sees the object, rather than what it sees.

    The Tiantai notion of inclusive principle 理具 encompasses dharmas that exist fully in the present moment, as well as dharmas that have existed in the past and will exist in the future. Like 'coins in a pocket' , in this 'omnicentric' picture of reality, all dharmas are arrayed side by side (Ziporyn 2014). All ordered patterns found within things are entailed by a single instant of thought. Tiantai Buddhism thus teaches the inconceivable object of contemplation 不可思議境 that blends reality and illusion 眞妄和合. It is inconceivable in that is indeterminable in its moral character and is beyond words. Both Buddha, oneʼs own mind, and the mind of other sentient beings are all "devoid of a univocally discernible identity" (Ziporyn 2013, 268). As far as their "intersubsumptive" character is concerned, there is no substantial difference between the Buddha, oneʼs own mind, and the mind of other sentient beings.

    In contrast to the pluralistic notion of multiple intersubsumptive truths presented by different perspectives on a reality that combines aspects of purity and impurity, Ziporyn (2014, 2013) characterizes the Huayan teaching as "absolute" in character in that it privileges an "ironic" form of coherence. In this ironic form of coherence enlightenment and harmony of all things are combined with indeterminacy and inexpressibility 不可說. In Huayan philosophical teachings, seemingly incongruous factors are united together by a principle of thusness that applies equally to both harmony and disharmony.

    十不二門指要鈔 T 1928.46.715c29

    References:

    Mou, Zongsan 牟宗三. 1989. Bore yu foxing 般若與佛性 . Taiwan:  Taiwan Xuesheng shuju.

    Ziporyn, Brook. 2013. Beyond Oneness and Difference: Li and Coherence in Chinese Buddhist Thought and its Antecedents. Albany, NY:  SUNY Press.

    ----. 2014. “Tiantai Buddhism.”  In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/buddhism-tiantai/.

    [Billy Brewster; source(s): Ziporyn, Ui, Nakamura]
  • Search SAT
  • Search INBUDS Database

  • Feedback

    [Dictionary References]

    Bukkyō jiten (Ui) 717

    Bulgyo sajeon 138a

    Bukkyōgo daijiten (Nakamura) 938d

    Ding Fubao {Digital Version}

    Bukkyō daijiten (Mochizuki) (v.9-10)476a

    Bukkyō daijiten (Oda) 1121-3



    Entry created: 2006-08-30

    Updated: 2019-04-11